Rideshare services like Uber and Lyft have transformed transportation throughout Amherst and across New York. But when accidents involving these services occur, the legal landscape becomes complicated. Rideshare accidents are not like ordinary car crashes. They involve overlapping insurance policies, multi-party liability, and unique challenges in establishing fault.
At Brown Chiari LLP, our rideshare accident lawyers help injured passengers, drivers, and others impacted by these crashes navigate the legal process. Whether the accident happened during a ride request, after drop-off, or while the driver was off-duty, we’re here to provide clear guidance and aggressive legal representation.

Unlike traditional motor vehicle accidents, rideshare accidents bring a number of added legal questions. For instance, was the driver actively working for Uber or Lyft at the time of the crash? Was the driver en route to pick up a passenger, or were they in between rides? These distinctions affect which insurance policy applies, either the driver’s personal auto insurance, the rideshare company’s commercial coverage, or sometimes both.
Insurance coverage in these cases can be difficult to pin down. Uber and Lyft maintain sizable liability insurance policies, but they don’t always accept responsibility easily. Meanwhile, the insurance company representing the rideshare driver may deny claims if the driver was logged into the app. Victims often find themselves going back and forth between insurers, while medical bills continue to climb.
This is why hiring a rideshare accident lawyer is essential. Our legal team evaluates every layer of coverage, from the driver’s personal insurance to the policy carried by Uber or Lyft. We determine which parties are legally responsible and pursue every available option to secure the compensation our clients deserve.
When a rideshare accident happens, the impact can be life-altering. Passengers and others involved may suffer serious injuries like fractures, soft tissue trauma, or even traumatic brain injuries. In more severe crashes, the injuries lead to permanent disability and a significant loss in quality of life.
The financial burden after such a crash can be overwhelming. Between medical expenses, lost income, and ongoing medical treatments, many accident victims are left struggling to stay afloat. The cost of physical rehabilitation, surgeries, prescriptions, and therapy can stretch on for years, especially in cases involving severe injuries.
And while insurance companies may offer quick settlements, those offers rarely reflect the full scope of damages. Our goal is to ensure that every dollar — from property damage and vehicle damage to emotional distress — is factored into your claim. At Brown Chiari LLP, we build a case that seeks fair compensation, not just what insurers want to pay.
Determining liability in a rideshare crash requires a close look at when and how the accident occurred. If the driver was actively engaged in a ride, Uber or Lyft’s commercial insurance may apply. If the accident happened while the app was off, only the driver’s personal coverage may be in effect. In some cases, another at fault party may be to blame, another driver, a distracted cyclist, or even a poorly maintained roadway.
Our legal team examines all contributing factors to pinpoint fault and prove liability. We use police reports, witness accounts, and sometimes accident reconstruction experts to understand how the crash unfolded. Whether it was caused by distracted driving, reckless lane changes, or a failure to obey traffic laws, we hold the right parties accountable.
In many cases, we’ve found that multiple drivers involved share blame. That’s why it’s critical to work with attorneys who understand the insurance networks tied to Uber and Lyft. We pursue all liable parties and ensure your legal claim covers every possible source of compensation.

Navigating a car accident claim after a rideshare crash can feel overwhelming. You may be dealing with mounting medical bills, unanswered questions from the insurance provider, and stress from lost time at work. Many victims are unsure about how to move forward, what their rights are, or whether they’re eligible for additional compensation.
Our attorneys guide clients through every stage of the legal process — from filing the claim and gathering evidence to negotiating a fair settlement or litigating the case if needed. We also protect you from tactics commonly used by insurers, including attempts to downplay injuries or shift blame to the injured party.
You may be entitled to recover damages for a range of losses, including medical costs, lost wages, non economic damages like pain and suffering, and in rare cases, punitive damages. Every case is different, which is why we take the time to fully evaluate the extent of your injuries, the impact on your day-to-day life, and your long-term medical outlook.
Rideshare companies have legal teams and insurers protecting their interests — you should too. At Brown Chiari LLP, our experienced attorneys are committed to fighting for the rights of accident victims across Amherst and Western New York. We bring years of experience handling car accident cases, including those involving Uber and Lyft, and understand how to navigate the unique challenges that come with ride sharing services.
Our firm offers personalized legal services, direct communication, and compassionate guidance throughout your case. We offer a free consultation to evaluate your claim and work on a contingency fee basis — so you don’t pay unless we win. We’ve recovered significant compensation for victims of car accidents, rideshare accidents, and other complex motor vehicle accidents, and we’re ready to help you do the same.
Learn more about Amherst Rideshare Accident Lawyer. Call Brown Chiari LLP at (716) 681-7190 to schedule your free, no-obligation consultation. You can also reach us anytime through our contact page. Let us help you take the first step toward justice and recovery.
Start by getting immediate medical attention, even if your injuries seem minor. Then, report the incident to law enforcement and request a police report. Avoid discussing fault with the insurance company or the rideshare driver until you've spoken with an attorney.
It depends. Uber and Lyft typically argue that their drivers are independent contractors, not employees. However, their commercial insurance policies may still apply if the crash happened during an active ride. A lawyer can help determine whether the rideshare company itself is liable.
You may be eligible to recover economic damages (like medical expenses, property damage, and lost wages) as well as non economic damages (such as pain and suffering). If gross negligence was involved, you may also pursue punitive damages.
Even if you weren’t a rideshare passenger, you still have a right to pursue a claim. Whether the rideshare driver or another at fault party was responsible, we can help you seek fair compensation for your injuries and losses.
In most New York rideshare accident cases, you have three years from the date of the crash to file a claim. However, there are exceptions and legal nuances that may shorten this window. Speaking with a lawyer promptly is the best way to protect your rights.